HSA vs FSA: Choosing the Best Employee Benefit
Offering the right benefits can make a huge difference in employee employee satisfaction and employee retention. Some benefits are more popular than others, and perks like health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off all play a role in attracting and keeping great talent. But when it comes to covering healthcare costs, two options often get mixed up—Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) and Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs).
Both let employees set aside money for medical expenses tax-free, which is a massive plus. But they come with different rules, restrictions, and incentives. Choosing the right one will help you be certain employees get the most out of their healthcare dollars. So, how do HSA vs FSA compare? Let’s break it down.
What Are HSAs and FSAs?
The main difference between an HSA vs FSA is that HSAs are owned by the employee and are portable, while FSAs are typically owned by the employer and come with strict time frames for using them. HSAs and FSAs both help employees save on healthcare costs, but they function differently. While an HSA acts more like a long-term savings account for medical expenses, an FSA offers short-term tax savings with stricter spending deadlines. Here’s a closer look at each option.
Health Savings Accounts (HSAs)
An HSA is a tax-advantaged savings account designed to help those with high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) cover medical expenses. Employees contribute pre-tax income, which lowers their taxable earnings while building a fund for healthcare costs like doctor visits, prescriptions, and medical procedures.
One of the standout features of an HSA is its flexibility. Unlike some other health benefit accounts, unused funds roll over indefinitely. This allows employees to save for future medical expenses. Apart from that, HSAs are employee-owned, which means the account stays with them even if they change jobs or leave their company. That's why many outlets call them “portable.”
Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs)
An FSA is another tax-advantaged account that helps employees pay for eligible medical expenses. Unlike HSAs, FSAs aren’t tied to a specific type of health insurance plan. This detail makes them accessible to a far wider range of employees.
But still, FSAs have stricter rules on fund usage. Most require employees to use the money within the plan year, though some employers offer limited rollover options or grace periods. Another key difference is ownership—FSAs are owned by the employer, which means employees may lose access to unused funds if they leave their job.
On top of this, a Dependent Care FSA is a pre-tax benefit account that helps employees pay for eligible childcare and dependent care expenses.
Both HSA and FSA differ from a Health Reimbursement Account (HRA), which is fully funded by the employer and can be used to reimburse medical expenses.
Gross vs. Net Pay: Key Differences, Explained →
Can Employers Offer both HSA and FSA?
Yes, employers can offer both an FSA and an HSA, but employees can't contribute to both (some exceptions apply, but generally, it works that way).
Key Differences Between HSA and FSA
While both HSAs and FSAs help employees manage healthcare expenses, they are different in several key areas, including eligibility, contribution limits, rollover rules, and ownership.
Eligibility Criteria
One of the primary differences is who qualifies for each account. HSAs are available only to individuals enrolled in a high-deductible health plan (HDHP). For 2024, for example, an HDHP had a minimum deductible of $1,600 for individuals and $3,200 for families. Additionally, those with other health coverage, including Medicare, were not eligible to contribute to an HSA.
In contrast, FSAs do not have specific health insurance requirements, which allow employees to participate irrespective of their plan. Still, FSAs must be offered by an employer, so employees cannot open one independently. For instance, an employee enrolled in a traditional low-deductible health plan would not qualify for an HSA but could contribute to an FSA if their employer provided the option.
Contribution Limits
Each account has annual contribution limits set by the IRS. In 2025, individuals can contribute up to $4,300 to an HSA, while families can contribute up to $8,550. Employees aged 55 and older are allowed an additional $1,000 catch-up contribution. FSAs, on the other hand, have a lower contribution limit of $3,300 per year. While employers can contribute to both types of accounts, FSA contributions cannot exceed the IRS limit when combined with employee contributions.
What are the HSA limits in 2025?
In 2025, HSA contribution limits have increased to $4,300 for individuals and $8,550 for family coverage. This is an increased cap compared to the $4,150 and $8,300 of 2024.
Rollover Rules
A major difference between HSAs and FSAs is how unused funds are handled. HSA funds roll over indefinitely and allow employees to build long-term savings for future healthcare needs. FSAs typically operate on a “use it now or lose for good” mode, which means that any unused funds at the end of the plan year are forfeited or given away. However, some employers invite employees to carry over up to $640 into the next year or provide a grace period of up to 2.5 months to use the remaining funds.
For instance, if an employee has $500 left in their FSA at year-end and their employer offers a carry-over option, they won’t lose the funds. Without this option, however, any unspent money would be forfeited.
Ownership and Portability
The stakeholder who owns the account is different for each option. HSAs belong to the employee. If an employee changes jobs, they can take their HSA with them and continue using the funds for medical expenses. FSAs, even so, are employer-owned, meaning any remaining balance is lost if the employee leaves their job unless they qualify for COBRA continuation coverage.
For example, an employee with $2,000 in an HSA who switches jobs can take the full amount with them. In contrast, an employee with an FSA who resigns will lose any unused funds unless they continue coverage through COBRA.
Tax Advantages of HSA and FSA
Both HSAs and FSAs offer significant tax benefits for employees and employers, but they work differently in certain areas.
Pre-Tax Contributions
One of the biggest advantages of both accounts is the ability to contribute pre-tax dollars. Contributions to an HSA or FSA are deducted from employee paychecks before taxes, which reduces taxable income. HSAs provide an additional benefit by allowing independent contributions, which are tax-deductible when filing taxes. Employers can also contribute tax-free to both HSAs and FSAs.
For example, an employee earning $50,000 per year who contributes $3,000 to an HSA will only be taxed on $47,000 of their income. The same tax savings apply to an FSA contribution, effectively lowering overall tax liability.
Tax-Free Withdrawals for Qualified Expenses
Both accounts allow tax-free withdrawals when used for qualified healthcare expenses, such as doctor visits, hospital stays, prescriptions, and vision expenses. Still, HSAs lend the most flexibility when it comes to non-medical withdrawals. Before age 65, withdrawing HSA funds for non-medical expenses incurs a 20% penalty along with income tax. After 65, non-medical withdrawals are still subject to regular income tax but no penalty, which makes an HSA a potential retirement savings tool.
FSAs, in contrast, must be used strictly for healthcare expenses. Non-medical withdrawals are not authorized, and employees must submit claims for reimbursement within the plan year. For example, an HSA holder who withdraws $2,000 for a vacation before turning 65 will owe a $400 penalty plus regular income tax, while an FSA holder simply would not be allowed to use their funds for anything apart from healthcare.
Tax Implications for Employers and Employees
Both HSAs and FSAs come with tax advantages for employers, as they lower the amount of payroll taxes they owe. Employer contributions to these accounts are tax-deductible, and because employee contributions lower taxable wages, companies save money on payroll taxes. Employees, in turn, benefit from lower taxable income and tax-free withdrawals for qualified medical expenses.
For example, if an employer has 100 employees contributing an average of $2,500 to FSAs, the company saves 7.65% in payroll taxes, amounting to approximately $19,125 in savings.
Contractor vs Full-time Employee: Key Differences Explained →
When to Choose HSA or FSA
Choosing between an HSA and an FSA depends on several factors, such as an employee’s healthcare needs, financial situation, and the type of health insurance they have.
When an HSA is the Right Choice
An HSA is ideal for employees enrolled in a high-deductible health plan who want to save for medical expenses while enjoying long-term financial benefits. Because HSA funds roll over year after year and can be invested, they work well for those who tend to anticipate low annual medical expenses but want to build a healthcare safety net over time.
For example, a young, healthy professional with hardly any health concerns may choose an HSA because they can contribute pre-tax dollars, let the funds grow, and use them tax-free later in life. Plus, employees who may switch jobs will benefit from a portable arrangement like this one.
When an FSA is the Right Choice
An FSA is a better option for employees who expect to have predictable medical expenses later in the year and want to take advantage of tax savings. Since FSAs require employees to use most of their funds before the plan year ends, they work well for covering ongoing healthcare costs such as regular prescriptions, therapy sessions, or planned procedures.
For example, an employee who knows they will spend $1,500 on their wisdom teeth all throughout the year (yes, you can feel sorry for them) may contribute that amount to an FSA to lower their taxable income. Or if someone has a child who needs medical help often, it might be better to have FSA money ready to use at the beginning of the year.
Just remember that FSAs are employer-owned, so if an employee leaves their job, they lose any unused FSA funds unless they qualify for COBRA continuation coverage, which is the policy's incredibly contrived name.
Upgrade people ops with advanced employee management software →
Using Tools Like TalentHR for Benefits Management
Both accounts offer tax advantages and help with medical expenses, but they serve different purposes. An HSA is a great fit for those who want a long-term savings option with flexibility and rollover benefits, while an FSA is ideal for employees who anticipate regular healthcare expenses and want to maximize short-term tax savings.
Managing employee benefits can be time-consuming, especially for small and growing businesses. Platforms like TalentHR help simplify the process as they coordinate benefits administration.
With a digital benefits management system, employers can gift employees with real-time access to their benefit options, contribution limits, and remaining balances. Automated reminders can also help employees use up their FSAs before the plan year ends or change their HSA contributions based on their healthcare needs.
Want to simplify benefits management and help employees make informed decisions? TalentHR makes it easy to automate your benefits program as it makes sure your team gets the most out of their options. Try TalentHR today for free!
