Replace Performance Improvement Plans with 7 Better Alternatives
Performance Improvement Plans, or PIPs, are a go-to measure for addressing performance issues in the workplace. On the front page, at least they seem practical since they're a structured way to point out shortfalls, set clear goals, and give struggling employees a chance to improve. Still, in practice, they’re often viewed as punitive measures rather than supportive ones. Many employees see PIPs as the corporate equivalent of a final warning, and they're a motivator to get worked up with anxiety and suspicion that they're on their final days at work.
So, instead of motivating employees to succeed, PIPs may actually cultivate resentment and disengagement. This begs an important question: Is there a better way to address performance challenges while sustaining a culture of growth and collaboration? The answer is in finding supportive alternatives that focus on development rather than discipline.
What is a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)?
A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a formalized process designed to help employees address underperformance. It typically outlines specific objectives for improvement, provides resources to support progress, and sets a clear timeline for meeting expectations. The goal is to guide employees back on track while making sure the organization’s performance standards are met.
Common Uses of PIPs
Organizations often prepare a PIP plan when employees face challenges such as consistent poor performance in key areas, failure to meet job responsibilities despite recent feedback, or reckless behavior that negatively affects team dynamics or productivity. These structured plans typically outline objectives, specify deadlines, and set regular follow-up meetings to monitor progress. For example, an employee struggling to meet deadlines might be placed on a PIP process that sets incremental milestones over the next three months to avoid missed deadlines.
Challenges with Traditional PIPs
Even though PIPs are supposed to help employees improve, they frequently backfire and come across as the opposite of that. Many workers see them as less of a chance to grow and more of a signal that their days at the company might be numbered. Instead of an underperforming employee, PIPs can create stress, fear, or even resentment—hardly the recipe for turning performance deficiencies around.
There is also the dilemma of skepticism. If a PIP feels like a one-sided ultimatum rather than a collaborative effort to address challenges, it can sour the relationship between employees and management. Employees may end up feeling isolated or even unfairly targeted, which only worsens the situation.
Given these issues, it’s clear that organizations need to rethink their approach to performance management. Adopting strategies that authentically support growth and development can set up a healthier workplace culture—one where an employee succeeds.
Employee Retention: 7 Effective Strategies for 2025 →
Why Replace PIPs?
As we’ve been discussing, PIPs may have good intentions, but in practice, they often do more harm than good. One major issue is how employees perceive them. Many workers view PIPs as a formalized path to termination rather than a sincere effort to help them improve. This perception triggers anxiety, stress, and defensiveness—emotions that rarely inspire better performance. When an employee feels like the company is more focused on documenting their mistakes than helping them succeed, it’s hard to stay motivated or engaged.
The negative impact of PIPs often extends beyond just the individual employee. Company culture can take a hit when PIPs become synonymous with failure. Colleagues may start seeing PIPs as a public signal that someone is on the way out, leading to gossip and speculation.
Retention is also interfered with. The stress and stigma associated with PIPs might push employees to quit, even if they might have turned things around with the right support. In fact, many employees placed on PIPs eventually leave their roles, whether they complete the plan successfully or not. This could result in costly turnover for companies, as recruiting and onboarding new talent is far more expensive than investing in the growth and development of existing employees.
By shifting to growth-oriented strategies—like regular coaching, development plans, and proactive support—companies can set up a culture where employees feel motivated to improve without the looming threat of formal corrective action. These methods focus on improving strengths instead of punishing weaknesses.
How Businesses Can Improve Company Culture and Succeed →
7 Alternatives to Performance Improvement Plans
Given the challenges of traditional PIPs, more and more organizations are looking for better ways to support employees and improve employee's current performance without creating an emotional climate of dissent or frustration. These alternatives focus on building a supportive, growth-oriented environment where employees feel able to succeed rather than focusing solely on correcting mistakes. Here are several functional alternatives to consider if you want to ditch your PIPs:
1. Regular Feedback and Coaching
One of the best ways to avoid a PIP and help employees correct their mistakes is by giving regular feedback and offering coaching along the way. Instead of waiting for annual reviews or waiting until performance issues become major problems, feedback should be ongoing. Companies can schedule regular feedback sessions where managers actively seek the employee's input on their performance and development.
Coaching, in particular, is a hands-on approach where the employee’s manager helps the worker acquire the skills they need to respond to challenges and grow professionally. Regular feedback and coaching can be the secret to keeping employees on track and showing them that their progress counts, day in and day out. All of this without a maligned PIP.
2. Goal Alignment and Development Plans
Aligning individual goals with the larger objectives of the company is a great way to create a sense of purpose for employees. Companies can make sure that performance goals are aligned with both the employee’s strengths and the expectations outlined in their job descriptions. And a plan to help them match these specs can be a good PIP replacement.
When employees know their personal goals are tied to company success, they’re more likely to be motivated and engaged in their work. Development plans are a fantastic way to map out measurable objectives and create a clear path forward. These plans can include both short-term goals—like completing a specific project—and long-term ambitions—like moving into a leadership role. Instead of drafting a PIP, companies can come up with these plans when they notice a shortfall.
3. Mentorship Programs
Mentorship programs are another great way to replace a PIP. Companies can run mentorship programs at the start of a fiscal year or whenever they detect a shortage that would otherwise be addressed with a PIP. There's no red flag associated with a mentorship program, which is precisely what a PIP is believed to have.
4. Skills Training and Workshops
Sometimes employees struggle with performance because they don’t have the right skills for the job. A PIP is not necessary to help them develop those skills once and for all. Skills training and workshops are a great way to address this, whether it’s technical training, leadership skills, or even soft skills like problem-solving and communication skills.
5. Performance Check-ins
Running in contrast to dreadful meetings in which managers hand out their formal performance review, or, more importantly, running in opposition to late-stage PIPs, performance check-ins are frequent, informal meetings where managers and employees discuss how things are going. These check-ins are a great way to spot potential issues early on and address them before they become bigger problems.
6. Peer Support Programs
Peer support programs are a good alternative to PIPs. They rely on colleagues—not managers—to help employees feel less isolated in their roles, as they know they have co-workers who understand their challenges and are willing to offer advice and support.
7. Wellness Initiatives
It’s hard to perform well at work if employees aren’t feeling their best physically or mentally. If you're considering running a PIP, you might directly tackle a root cause and go with a wellness initiative. Plenty of wellness initiatives don't involve offering employees a gym pass; some cost no money, and almost every one of them can help an employee feel better. Although, be wary of using them casually. A wellness initiative will only work out if the HR team can confidently assess that the employee's shortcomings are part of a larger mental health issue. And one of the best ways to understand why an employee is underperforming is with HR software which can gather people analytics.
4 Self-Evaluation Examples for Your Next Performance Review →
How to Choose the Right Alternative
Now that we’ve covered some effective alternatives to PIPs, it’s time to figure out how to choose the right approach for your organization. The best alternative will depend on the obstacles your employees are facing, as well as your company’s culture and values. Here are a few key considerations for making the right choice:
Finding the Root Cause of Performance Issues
The first step in choosing the right alternative is to understand why an employee might be underperforming in the first place. Is it a skills gap? Poor communication? A lack of motivation? Or perhaps something outside of work is affecting their performance? Determining the root cause of the problem helps you sort out which alternative will be most favorable.
For example, if an employee is struggling with time management, coaching, and skills training might be more appropriate. If personal issues are detrimental to their work, giving them a thrifty wellness perk could make a real difference—even more impactful than a stigmatized PIP. The best way to find out is with HR software that collects people analytics and scores on metrics like engagement.
Matching Alternative Strategies with Company Culture and Values
Your company’s culture plays a big role in defining which strategies will work best. If your organization's principles include transparency and open communication, regular feedback and performance check-ins will probably be a good fit. If collaboration and teamwork are central to your culture, mentorship or peer support programs may resonate more.
Adapting Plans to Each Employee
Every worker is different, and the ideal way to do their job most effectively will depend on what they are lacking—or what they could use. For example, a new employee might need more structure and training, while a seasoned employee may prefer a more autonomous approach with regular check-ins.
Replace One-Time PIPs with Ongoing People Analytics
Shifting from traditional PIPs to more supportive, ongoing, and growth-focused strategies can help companies actually deal with challenges on time and not as a last resort. Here’s how to roll out these other options:
- Check your current methods: Evaluate your ongoing performance management processes to spot areas for improvement and figure out which alternatives will be most beneficial.
- Adjust to each case: Offer each employee a single, well-picked alternative to a PIP.
- Train your teams: Provide training for both managers and employees to make sure everyone understands and adopts the new approach to performance improvement.
- Push for a supportive culture: Always advertise a culture that supports correcting problems instead of hunting down a scapegoat.
Plus, to measure success, track the following metrics:
- Employee engagement and morale: You can use HR software to measure employee engagement and get a score for each of your workers.
- Turnover rates: Watch for a decline in turnover, as more supportive strategies can help retain employees.
- Performance improvements: Track KPIand document progress to see if employees are achieving their goals and improving productivity.
- Employee growth: Monitor how employees progress in their roles and whether they’re staying longer with the company.
To support this transition, consider using tools like TalentHR’s employee performance tool to automate performance tracking and feedback. Also, integrate TalentLMS so you can continually train employees and help employees bounce back from their mistakes without placing a PIP over them.
Sign up for free to TalentHR today and try all the features with the Premium plan 14-day trial. No credit card needed.
